Institute for Science and International Security Logo

ISIS Reports

1999 Scorecard on Fissile Material Controls

January 1, 2000

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               
  Category   Grade
  I) Ending the production   of fissile material for nuclear weapons   C
  a) Unilateral initiatives   by the five acknowledged nuclear weapon states to end the production   of fissile materials for weapons   A-
  b) Ending the production   in other states   D
  c) Obtaining a Fissile   Material Cutoff Treaty   B-
  II) Protecting and   reducing the military stocks of fissile materials in the nuclear   weapon states   C
  a) Declaring military   stocks to be excess   C-
  b) Placing excess military   stocks under international safeguards or verification   B
  c) Disposing of excess   HEU   B-
  d) Disposing of excess   plutonium   D+
  e) Establishing verifiable   warhead dismantlement   C-
  III) Protecting fissile   materials from theft   C+
  a) Improving protection   and accounting systems in the Former Soviet Union   D+
  b) Improving physical   protection world-wide   B+
  IV) Creating inventory   transparency   C+
  a) Military stocks   D+
  b) Civil stocks   B+
  V) Ending the proliferation   of nuclear weapons   C+
  a) Strengthened IAEA   safeguards   A-
  b) Working towards NPT   universality and nuclear-weapon-free zones   B-
  c) Dealing with violators   of international non-proliferation commitments or inspections   D
  d) Improving export   controls   C+
  VI) Reducing the   threat posed by civil stocks of fissile material   C-
  a) Minimizing stocks   of separated civil plutonium   D+
  b) Eliminating civil   HEU   C
  VII) Establishing   acceptable nuclear waste repositories   F


  Overall Grade of   all Categories:   C

email us twitter share on facebook